Policy recommendation 1: Protect and restore
Policy recommendation 1: Protect and restore
Ensure business and financial actors protect nature and restore degraded ecosystems
Recommendation 1: Ensure business and financial actors protect nature and restore degraded ecosystems
Overview
Nature must be protected and restored for the benefit of all stakeholders, following a rights-based approach consistent with international human rights law. Avoiding negative impacts on the remaining intact ecosystems must be a top priority. To create a level playing field, governments should enable, require and incentivize business and financial actors to play their part in the conservation and restoration of ecosystems at a landscape level, with respect for the rights and practices of Indigenous Peoples and local communities.
This would contribute to implementing Targets 1, 2, 3 and 4 of the Global Biodiversity Framework.
Ask 1: Conversion ban in key protected areas
Strictly ban any commercial and/or industrial land use conversion or resource extraction in IUCN categories I-IV Protected Areas or equivalent, with needed exceptions for activities by Indigenous Peoples and local communities, and ensure that any development in Key Biodiversity Areas (KBAs) is avoided wherever possible or follows a robust permitting and licensing system and does not have a negative impact on the overall biodiversity values for which these areas are designated.
Justification: Governments should not give authorization to commercial development to convert critical natural ecosystems in IUCN categories I-IV Protected Areas or equivalent. A strong enforcement of these conversion bans will be essential, coupled with anti-corruption measures. Exceptions can be made for carefully managed sustainable development and extraction activities by Indigenous Peoples and local communities.
For Key Biodiversity Areas (KBAs) not covered by IUCN categories I-IV, strict environmental permitting and licensing is crucial to ensure the overall biodiversity values for which these areas are designated are preserved. KBAs are a universally adopted concept used as indicators for SDGs 14 and 15, and Targets 1 and 3 and as safeguards of IFC PF6 and Equator Principles Banks. Requiring all businesses to comply with the same environmental standards promotes fair competition.
Ask 2: Deforestation and conversion free rules
Align land tenure, permitting, and integrated spatial planning with deforestation and conversion-free objectives while adopting binding due diligence legislation to eliminate legal and illegal deforestation and conversion of natural ecosystems across key forest-risk commodities.
Justification: Global deforestation has been estimated at 10 million hectares each year and land-use change is the main driver of biodiversity loss worldwide, with 75% of the world’s land surface already significantly altered. Voluntary corporate progress has been insufficient. To achieve global land use targets, we need to address the supply side as well as the demand side. On the supply side, strong rules and enforcement are needed, including by improving the capacity of public agencies. On the demand side, mandatory due diligence legislation is crucial to foster transparency in the supply chain, in particular for high-risk sectors.
Due diligence legislation should follow a risk-based approach and require the collection of relevant information, risk assessment and risk mitigation measures. Legislation should not inadvertently adversely impact SMEs and developing economies in the Global South. Capacity development programs should be offered to countries that need them. This would incentivize agricultural businesses to invest in sustainable sourcing and production practices and ensure fair competition among businesses.
Ask 3: Restoration obligation at project level
Where impacts are unavoidable, require industries to uphold strict social and environmental standards and to conduct ecological restoration work throughout a project’s lifespan and upon termination, including through mandatory upfront restoration investments and auditable financial provisions, when relevant in co-management with Indigenous Peoples and local communities.
Justification: Following a ‘polluter pays’ principle, companies should be responsible for their impact on any terrestrial, aquatic or marine ecosystems. To contribute to achieving nature-positive outcomes, companies must follow the mitigation hierarchy: first avoid and minimize negative impacts, then implement no-net loss commitments, and then be required to restore any direct or indirect damage caused. Restoration should aim to enhance ecosystem functions over time.
Upfront investments and auditable financial provisions to support restoration are essential to hold companies accountable for their responsibilities and commitments during and at the end of a project’s lifetime. Restoration obligations, based on a “pay-as-you-go basis”, should be enforced priority as a priority for high-impact sectors such as extractive industries.
Ask 4: Restoration incentives beyond operations
Incentivize business and financial institutions to invest in restoration projects beyond their own operations and within their value chains through sectoral policies, fiscal mechanisms and tax incentives to achieve nature-positive goals.
Justification: Beyond requirements to restore impacted ecosystems at project level, the private sector should be encouraged and incentivized to invest in ecological restoration at a landscape level, across and beyond their value chains. This acknowledges their historical contribution to ecosystem degradation. These investments should not be considered as compensation or offsets. They should be included as part of companies’ nature-positive strategies and as a strategic investment in long-term resilience and adaptation due to the essential services ecosystems provide for business activities.
Restoration also creates jobs, fosters economic growth, and drives innovation. Co-management with Indigenous Peoples and local communities should take place when relevant.
Find out more
Download the full Policy Recommendations